Iconic ‘Eye’ Windows Sold at Estate Sale of Wisconsin’s Amityville Horror House

Amityville Horror props were sold at an estate sale this weekend at the Wisconsin lakehouse that served as the iconic haunted house in the 2005 film.
Amityville Horror house in Wisconsin

An estate sale was held over the weekend, on May 5, 6, and 7, at the Victorian lakehouse in Salem, Wisconsin where the 2005 Amityville Horror remake was filmed. The sale drew crowds who either just wanted to get a closer look at the historic home, or were just interested in it for its film history. According to the Kenosha News, the film production spent $60,000 to fit the house with a fake facade resembling the notorious house on Ocean Ave in Amityville, New York where 23-year-old Ronald J. DeFeo Jr. murdered his entire family in 1974.

Amongst the various items for sale over the weekend was a bed used by actor Ryan Reynolds to shoot a scene, available for $70, and the iconic “eye” windows from the facade, which sold for $300 each.

The house, known as Oakwood Manor, is also for sale. The massive 3,548-square-foot Queen Anne built circa 1880 includes six bedrooms, two bathrooms, original wood staircase, an enclosed wrap-around porch, a one-lane bowling alley in a separate building on the property, 500 feet of lakefront property on Silver Lake, and a boathouse and gazebo overlooking the lake.

The Amityville Horror house in Wisconsin

Wisconsin Amityville Horror house

Wisconsin Amityville Horror house entrance

Landing and stained glass window

Amityville Horror house dining room

Wisconsin Amityville Horror house gazebo and boat house

Wisconsin Amityville Horror house bowling alley

But does it come with any ghosts? Probably not, since it’s a long way from the real Amityville Horror. Also, the real estate listing does not include a Native American burial ground.

A house this old, though, is sure to have some stories of its own.

Wisconsin house used in Amityville Horror 2005
The house as seen in The Amityville Horror (2005)

5 replies
  1. Avatar
    Mark says:

    Great story! You are right the house does have a colorful history of its own! It was once part of the Jefferson Ice company. They supplied ice to people in Chicago and Milwaukee areas.

    I am the one who was lucky enough to get the iconic “Amityville” quarter-round windows. I couldn’t believe they were still in the attic! I have a link to photos of them if anyone wants to see them.

    Reply
    • Avatar
      Jeremy L Barth says:

      Mark I’d love to see pics those! I live in Kenosha and unfortunately I didn’t find out about this sale until a week ago. I’m bummed because I’m a film memorabila collector. Did you buy anything else? Are you Will to sell anything you may have acquired from the sale? I’d be interested in one of the windows. I have CASH and will make it worth your while!
      Hit me up if you would consider selling anything you may have got there, especially just one of the windows, but anything else as well. Contact me at radiancemultimedia@gmail.com

      Reply
      • Avatar
        Mark says:

        I would hate the idea of separating the pair of windows. I do have a set of wood pillars that I bought with the windows. I was going to use the pillars in a display with the windows, but I don’t have the space.

        Reply
        • Avatar
          Jodi says:

          Who can I speak to about this house. I know two people who have worked on this house, one of which was during filming and the other, shortly after filming, one person has now passed and the other experienced a horrific instance since then. So there are additions to the “curse” of this movie.

          Reply

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply to Mark Cancel reply